The Best Sump Pump for Dirty Water: Top 5 Product Reviews & Buying Guide

Sump pumps can be an invaluable tool for homeowners. Whether you’re on a basement remodeling project or just want to make sure your house stays dry and safe, these tools are well worth the investment. But with so many different models available, it can be hard to know which one is the best sump pump for dirty water.

Today, we’ve researched and rounded up 5 of the best sump pumps for dirty water. Our buying guide will help you learn more about what makes a great sump pump, and our product reviews will help you decide which model is right for your home. Let’s get started!

5 Best Sump Pumps for Dirty Water

We list the 5 best sump pumps for dirty water based on buyers' reviews and extensive research.

1. Prostormer 1/2 HP Submersible Sump Pump

1/2 HP Submersible Sump Pump, Clean/Dirty Water Pump 2100GHP with Float Switch for Pool Draining, Hot Tub, Flood Drain
  • 【Kindly Tips】 : When you start use the pump you must be submerged into the water at a slight angle to allow the remaining air to escape .
  • 【Kindly Tips】There is an air vent on the pump so when the pump is working, there will be water leaking out from here, this is a normal phenomenon It’s not that the pump is damaged.
  • 【Muti Outlet Water】:There have 3 different outlet (1 inch ,1-1/4 inch, 1-1/2 inch ) , can choose from according to the flow rate , The bigger the flow is, the wider the outlet should be.
  • 【Powerful Sump Pump】: Equipped with 1/2HP power motor can deliver up to 2100GPH and max delivery height can be reached 16 feet . Suitable for ponds, swimming pools, sprinkler systems, irrigation systems, gardening, rain buckets, flooded basement, large aquariums .
  • 【Auto Float Switch】: When the water level rises above the pump, the pump will automatically start working under the control of the float switch. When the water level is below the pump, you should lift the float for pumping. Note: Once the pump fails to pump water, you should immediately lower the float switch or cut off the power. Otherwise, it will cause the coil to burn out.

This powerful Prostormer 1/2 HP Submersible Sump Pump is perfect for various settings, including ponds, sprinkler systems, swimming pools, irrigation systems, and gardening. With a max delivery height of 16 feet, this pump can handle even the most challenging tasks. And thanks to the 1/2HP power motor, the Prostormer can deliver up to 2100 GPH, making short work of any job.

This top-of-the-line pump is designed for maximum performance and durability and can handle even the most challenging pumping applications. In addition, it comes with three different outlet sizes to choose from, so you can find the perfect flow rate for your needs.

The Prostormer 1/2 HP Submersible Sump Pump is the ideal solution for keeping your basement or crawl space dry. Thanks to the float switch, the pump will automatically kick on and start working when the water level rises.

When the water level drops back down, you can simply lift the float switch, and the pump will stop. If the pump ever fails to pump water, you can quickly lower the float switch or cut off the power to prevent damage to the coil.

This incredible pump has a durable sealing structure and a thermoplastic body that keeps it from rusting – perfect for wet basements. With its 1/2 HP motor, this pump can easily move large amounts of water and keep your basement safe and dry.

Installation is quick and easy, and the included instructions make it a breeze. Simply position the pump in your sump pit, connect the discharge hose, and plug in the power cord. The Prostormer 1/2 HP Submersible Sump Pump will do the rest, automatically removing water as it accumulates.

2. Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate 1/3 Hp Submersible Sump Pump

Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump, 1/3 Hp
  • Professional-grade, 3/10 HP submersible pump for residential dewatering (sump) or effluent (septic tank systems) use.

Zoeller pumps are engineered for performance and quality, and the Mighty-mate 1/3 hp submersible sump pump is no exception. This powerful little pump is perfect for small spaces, making it easy to get the job done without taking up a lot of space. Cast iron switch housing and thermoplastic base make this pump durable and long-lasting, while the float switch provides automatic operation.

This battery-powered pump is compact and lightweight, making it easy to transport and install. And with its corrosion-resistant housing, it can handle even the most challenging environments. Weighing in at only 21 pounds, this pump can easily be moved around to the most convenient spot. In addition, with its 1/3 horsepower motor, it can quickly and easily move large amounts of water out of your home.

The Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate, 1/3 Hp Submersible Sump Pump, is perfect for home or office use. This reliable pump is built tough and can handle up to 43 GPM. With its 115 volt motor, the Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate 1/3 Hp Submersible Sump Pump is easy to install and operate.

Simply place the pump in your sump pit, connect the discharge hose, and plug in the power cord. The Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate 1/3 Hp Submersible Sump Pump will do the rest, automatically removing dirty water as it accumulates.

3. PROSTORMER 1HP Stainless Steel Sump Pump

Stainless Steel Sump Pump, Prostormer 1HP 3700GPH Submersible Clean/Dirty Water Pump with Float Switch for Fresh Water, Mains Water, and Pool Water
  • ⚡⚡【Kindly Tip 1】When you start use the pump you must be submerged into the water at a slight angle to allowthe remaining air to escape.⚡⚡
  • ⚡⚡【Kindly Tip 2】If the pump fails to work, you can first check the fault self-check in the manual for troubleshooting.⚡⚡
  • 🔥【 Stainless Steel】The body of the water pump is made of stainless steel, which improves the quality of the water pump and makes the water pump less likely to be damaged.
  • 🔥【Multi Outlet Sizes】3 different diameters outlets (1 inch ,1-1/4 inch, 1-1/2 inch) to adapte for different size hoses as needed according to the flow rate. The bigger the flow is, the wider the outlet should be, suitable for many different scenes.
  • 🔥【1HP High Power】Prostormer Sump Pump uses 1HP power, which is more efficient than ordinary sump pump; Max 3700 Gallon Per Hour rating tackles any draining job at a fraction of the time.

The Prostormer 1HP SS Sump Pump can handle up to 233.47 liters per minute of flow rate – perfect for larger basements or areas with a high water table. A lifting height of 26 feet can easily clear away any excess water. And thanks to its red and stainless steel design, it will look great in any setting!

The pump's body is made of sturdy stainless steel, making it less likely to be damaged than other water pumps. Make sure your family is safe from water damage with this robust and reliable sump pump.

The Sump Pump is perfect for a wide range of applications. Three different outlet sizes (1 inch, 1 1/2 inch, 1 1/4 inch diameters) can be adapted to various hose sizes according to the water flow rate. The higher the flow is, the broader the outlet should be, making it fitting for many different settings.

This powerful pump uses 1 horsepower of power, making it more effective than your average sump pump. In addition, its Max 3700 GPH rating means it can handle any draining job quickly and easily. And thanks to its stainless steel construction, this pump is built to last. So if you're looking for a reliable sump pump that can get the job done, the Prostormer 1HP Steel Sump Pump is perfect.

This pump is not meant to be used continuously (for example, as a pond's recirculation pump). Therefore, the life of the pump will be significantly shortened due to this application.

4. DEKOPRO 1HP 750W Dirty Water Sump Pump  

DEKOPRO Sump Pump 1HP 3302GPH 750W Submersible Clean/Dirty Water Pump Swimming Pool Garden Tub Pond Flood Drain w/Float Switch and Long 16ft Cable
  • POWERFUL SUMP PUMP:750 Watt, 1 HP motor. Max Lift: 16 Feet; 3302 Gallon Per Hour rating tackles any draining job at a fraction of the time. This pump easily passes solids up to 1" in diameter. GREAT for flooded area, swimming pools, cellars or garden pond.
  • MULTI OUTLET SIZE: Submersible Water Pump is equipped w/ screw thread in GHT 3/4" or NPT5/8". Three fittings with different diameters for outflow( GHT 3/4", NPT 1", φ38, G 1-1/2") to choose from according to the flow rate.
  • AUTO FLOAT SWITCH:Start/stop automatically. When water level is below 4.7 inch, it will automatically disconnect the power; when water level rises above 4.7 inch, the pump will start again. Cut off immediately when pump fails to pump water to prevent the coil from getting burned.
  • HIGH-QUALITY MATERIALS:Thermoplastic composite material is highly rugged. Designed and manufactured in line with the valid safety requirements. Thermoplastic body resists corrosion as there are not exposed metal parts. Lower noise and energy-efficient. Oil free motor requires no maintenance.
  • GREAT FOR DRAINING:Great to Drain the Dirty Water from the Pond, Garden Pond, or Water Tanks. Great to move water for garden irrigation or cleaning your yard or road.

With its massive 750 watts, 1 HP motor, this pump can easily lift water 16 feet high, perfect for tackling flooded areas, swimming pools, cellars, etc. And if you're worried about solids clogging up the works, don't be – the DEKOPRO 1HP 750W Dirty Water Sump Pump can pass particles up to 1″ in diameter!

The DEKOPRO 1HP 750W Dirty Water Sump Pump is perfect for tackling any draining job quickly and efficiently. With a 3302 Gallon Per Hour rating, this pump can easily handle even the most difficult tasks. In addition, the durable construction ensures that it will stand up to abuse.

It features a multi-outlet size design with a 3/4″ or NPT5/8″ screw thread and three fittings with different diameters for outflow. The DEKOPRO sump pump also features an auto float switch that automatically starts and stops the pump.

When the water level is below 4.7 inches, it will disconnect the power to prevent the coil from burning out. And when the water level rises above 4.7 inches, the pump will start up again. This makes it easy to keep your basement or crawl space dry without constantly monitoring the pump.

This pump is made of high-quality materials and is designed for easy use. With its thermoplastic composite material, this pump is highly rugged and corrosion-resistant. Additionally, it is designed according to valid safety requirements, making it a safe choice for your home or business. The oil-free motor is energy efficient and requires no maintenance, making it an excellent choice for those who want an easy-to-use pump that will get the job done.

This reliable pump is great for moving water for garden irrigation or cleaning your yard or road. A powerful 1HP motor can easily handle large volumes of dirty water. So don't let dirty water problems slow you down – get the DEKOPRO Dirty Water Sump Pump today!

5. Wayne 57736-WYN1 WWB Waterbug 1/4 HP Sump Pump

Wayne 57736-WYN1 WWB Waterbug 1/4 HP Auto On/Off Water Removal Tool, Yellow
  • Don’t Let Standing Water Bug You - The WAYNE WaterBUG AUTO is your new ultimate automatic multi-purpose water removal tool. This pump turns on and off automatically, so you can just set it and forget it!
  • Get Rid of Water Quickly - This WWB AUTO water pump will get your basement or yard virtually dry by pumping up to 1900 GPH and removing water down to 1/2”.
  • Removal Options - Side discharge is ideal for easy water removal from flat open surfaces: flat roofs, flooded basements, standing water in yard, etc.
  • Additional Features - Corrosion-resistant discharge outlet, with tethered cap seals, fit any standard garden hose. Multi-ring suction strainer filters debris, keeping it clear from the suction intake to minimize clogging.
  • Quality You Deserve - Proudly assembled in the USA for quality you can trust. Warrantied for 1 year for dependable, efficient performance.

The powerful Wayne 57736-WYN1 WWB 1/4 HP Sump Pump can handle up to 32 gallons of water per minute, perfect for even the most challenging flooding situations. It's also made from durable brass construction and weighs only 8 pounds. You can move and store it anywhere with a small 11 x 11 x 10 inches footprint.

This powerful little pump can take care of the standing water to get back to your life. With its automatic on/off function, it’s easy to set up and use – just plug it in and let it do its thing. And because WAYNE makes it, you know it’s a quality product that will stand up to whatever water throws at it.

This powerful sump pump can pump up to 1900 GPH, making it ideal for quickly removing large amounts of water. It can also remove water down to 1/16″, so you can be sure that your basement or yard will be virtually dry.

When the weather turns bad, and rain starts to pour, you'll be glad you have the Wayne 57736-WYN1 WWB Waterbug 1/4 HP Sump Pump. This powerful little pump can quickly remove water from surfaces like flat roofs, flooded basements, and yards with standing water. In addition, its side discharge feature is easy to use and easy to clean up after.

This pump is proudly assembled in the United States, and a 1-year warranty backs it for your peace of mind. With its efficient design, this pump can handle continuous operation with ease.

Buying Guide for the Best Sump Pump for Dirty Water

If you're looking for the best sump pump for dirty water, there are a few things you'll need to keep in mind.

Material quality

Sump pumps are made from various materials, including thermoplastic composite, cast iron, and steel. Thermoplastic composite is a good choice for a lightweight and long-lasting pump. Cast iron can be quite heavy but offers excellent durability. Steel is a great choice for those who want a sump pump that's both powerful and affordable.

Power

The power rating of your sump pump affects how well it performs in different water conditions, so it's essential to choose one with enough power for your needs. Look for pumps with ratings between 1/4 to 1HP to find the best fit for your application.

Sump Pump Flow Rate

The flow rate of your sump pump is another important consideration. This is how much water the pump can move in a given amount of time. A higher flow rate means the pump can move more water, ideal for applications like quickly removing large amounts of water from a flooded basement.

Horsepower (HP)

The horsepower (HP) of your sump pump also affects its performance. A higher HP rating means the pump can move more water, ideal for larger flooding situations.

Max Supply Height

The max supply height is how high the sump pump can lift water. A higher rating means the pump can lift water to a greater height, which is ideal for applications like irrigating your garden.

Outlet Connection Size

The outlet connection size measures the hose diameter that attaches to the pump. A larger diameter hose can move more water, so it's ideal for those who need to move large volumes of water quickly.

Noise level

The noise level of your sump pump is an important consideration. A quieter pump will be easier to use, especially if you need to run it in a basement that's also used as a living space.

Warranty

When choosing a sump pump, be sure to check the warranty. A longer warranty period means the manufacturer has more faith in their product, so it's a good indication of quality.

The Best Sump Pump for Dirty Water FAQs

Can a sump pump pump dirty water?

Yes, a sump pump can be used to remove dirty water effectively. Factors that affect its performance include the power rating, flow rate, and outlet size of the pump. In general, high-powered pumps with a large flow rate are best for removing dirty water from flooded areas.

Which type of pump is best for handling dirty water?

There is no definitive answer as the best type of pump for handling dirty water depends on the specific application. However, high-powered pumps with a large flow rate are best for quickly removing large volumes of dirty water from flooded areas.

Can a sump pump handle sediment?

Generally, sump pumps are not designed to handle sediment and other debris. To remove sediment from dirty water, you may need to use a separate filter or sieve before pumping the water.

Why is the water in my sump pump dirty?

There are several potential reasons why water may be dirty in your sump pump. For example, if the pump is not maintained correctly or has been damaged, it may not be able to remove sediment and other debris from the water, resulting in dirty water. Other possible causes include worn-out seals or a clogged intake filter.

What's the difference between a clean water pump and a dirty water pump?

Clean Water Pumps will be used wherever the water would be unlikely to contain particles, and they tend to operate to between 5 & 10 mm minimum height as opposed to the usual 25 – 50 mm of a dirty water pump as they don't need to allow for particles passing through the pump.

Final Words

When choosing a sump pump for dirty water, it's important to consider the different factors affecting its performance. Factors like the flow rate, outlet size, and horsepower rating will determine how well the pump handles large volumes of water.

In general, high-powered pumps with a large flow rate are best for quickly removing dirty water from flooded areas. To learn more about sump pumps and their different features, check out our guide on the best sump pumps for dirty water.

We hope this guide helped you find the best sump pump for your needs. If you have any questions or comments, please reach out to us.

Thank you for reading!

Sump Pump Advisor
Logo